Photo Credit: Kevin O’Sullivan
Puscifer are a… unique band. But then again, Maynard James Keenan is a pretty unique creative. Although better known for his work with Tool and A Perfect Circle, Puscifer proudly sits with its older siblings with an equally diverse, eccentric and generally brilliant discography; because, while Tool and A Perfect Circle have their own, distinctive quirks and calling cards, Puscifer sits in a private, experimental vat where Maynard, Mat Mitchell and Carina Round can just toss in their thoughts, feelings and whatever they’ve picked up since the last record to produce something that’s, again, unique. Broadly speaking, Puscifer’s an ‘experimental electro-rock’, but that’s so reductive when considering just what the band does — rather, they’re an outfit that blurs the lines between music, comedy and theatrical performance. It’s got lore, having developed an entire universe of eccentric characters, surreal storylines and elaborate stage productions. Their last London headline appearance came in June 2023, when they brought the Existential Reckoning show to the O2 Forum Kentish Town, running around stage as secret agents while chasing Roswell Greys with guns. Three years on, and with a new album in Normal Isn’t, it was time to descend into their delicious lunacy once more.
It’s a fairly wild choice to have comedian Dave Hill as your support act, but then, for a band that once took a Lucha Libre wrestling troupe named Luchafer on the road with them during the Money Shot tour, it felt pretty on brand. And, as Hill emerged wearing a chrome, mirror-ball-esque helmet while riding a bike and doing press ups… yeah, makes sense.
What followed was a surprisingly physically demanding, near-constantly breathless half-hour of comedy. He had the audience chanting his name with the fervour of a desperation-fuelled cult leader, as he welcome everyone back to London, “the crown jewel of… this part of England”, and it was hard to tell how much felt like comedy and how much was just him. Hill’s set was a sort of ADHD sufferer’s fever dream, with one absurd premise tumbling into the next before anyone had quite processed the previous one. He took musical requests like a living jukebox, offering up some Iron Maiden, some Van Halen and Ozzy’s Crazy Train, before offering the crowd some Poundland slogans. “Poundland — we sell everything but dignity”. Next, weirdly specific London chat up lines. “Are you the Tube on New Year’s Eve between 11:45 and 4:15am? Because I would like to ride you free of charge.”
It was somewhere between gloriously ridiculous and ridiculously ridiculous; a good portion of the crowd were swept up in the manic revelling, but perhaps it was just as well that Hill was given only half an hour. The act retained its peculiar charm without having the opportunity to outstay its welcome. 7/10
British Airways ARC, meanwhile, proved an almost uncannily appropriate setting for Puscifer. The new venue, a triumphantly futuristic-looking venue of gleaming metal and an amphitheatre-esque balcony, offered a surprising amount of theatrical potential — perfect for Puscifer’s somewhat vaudevillian whimsy! Though, spoiler alert, the night was a little less whimsical than existing fans might have expected.
The band emerged silhouetted behind bars of blue light, piercing spotlights cutting through the darkness and into the crowd. Carina Round’s striking costume – a sanguine, Hunger Games-esque dress, a set of mountainous pointed shoulders framing her head – added to the macabre, almost otherworldly tableau. The space felt perfect for the group; customisable enough to accommodate the group’s stranger impulses, and a stage big enough to let loose with whatever proclivities the group had. Though, from the balcony above, it was just a shame that health and safety ruined the atmosphere by having the overhead lights on!
Yet there was something of a surprise in how comparatively restrained the performance felt. Some of the pantomimic elements that have made previous tours such a spectacle seemed conspicuously absent. The grave seriousness of the group’s presentation was impressive in its own right, but a slight disappointment after the campy absurdity of secret agents exchanging shots with alien greys or luchadores fighting in a ring. Though, each Puscifer tour is its own beast, with its own production, its own performance, all based on the theme of the relevant album — in some ways, Normal Isn’t seems to lean more into that more austere, stern aesthetic, and the night’s relative lack of frivolity if anything stayed more true to the band’s history than if something had been shoehorned in.
Either way, you don’t need production to enjoy a Puscifer show. You could stand there with your eyes closed and you’d still more than get your money’s worth — Puscifer are incredible live. Both vocally and instrumentally, everything is always as tight and polished as you’d could ever want; more so, really, with just how much ‘more’ each track seemed to offer than its record counterpart. Thrust feels darker, more insidious; Self Evident more demanding in its urgency; title track Normal Isn’t s scarily mesmeric. The Algorithm, saw liquid amber light slither around the bars behind the band, bathing the stage in an eerie facsimile of warmth; Pendulum hypnotically plodded along, Maynard’s mic stand simultaneously a swaying metronome and an upraised rifle. Horizons, the venue’s first taste of 2011’s Conditions Of My Parole had the crowd roaring in excitement, Maynard and Carina on podiums on either side of the stage — although from the balcony a good chunk of the introductory video was sadly blocked by the lighting scaffolding — and the beams of light hemming the group in during Mantastic felt like neon prison bars, Maynard’s normal serpentine croon taking on a distinct growl… even as he vigorously exercised what looked like a Shake Weight. At last, some of that signature Puscifer absurdity coming to the fore.
Bullet Train to Iowa was another welcome moment, the sole Existential Reckoningtrack to survive the inevitable setlist cull, and then it was time for the surprise end of the first half of the set: The Remedy
Let’s get this out of the way. The Remedy is a fantastic song. Even without some of the fun that’s characterised the track so much in previous tours, the sheer venom and despair in the track is unparalleled. Seeing Round and Keenan spinning in circles like a descent to Hell before exchanging mock volleys using guns and crossbows was as bizarre a surprise as normal, but it’s always everything you could want in a live track.
Then, as abruptly as it began, the action stopped. The lights came up, the stage filled with elevator music, and the band announced an intermission. At least the band’s relatively early on-stage time worked in its favour!
The second half opened with The Humbling River, its haunting electro-folk arrangement giving Round room to become menacingly ethereal, particularly amid the harmonies of the group as a whole; the repeated bridge seemed to stretch towards infinity, while the song’s sparse, atmospheric quality offered a striking contrast to the more elaborate production elsewhere. ImpetuoUs followed, its eerie atmosphere keeping the room suspended, motionless; Momma Sed saw Round and Keenan elevated at the back of the stage, somehow embodying both imperious authority and concerned guardian, while the primarily instrumental Seven One both let the rest of the band let loose and served as a bit of a reset for the vocalists… and a reminder to everyone present that the rest of the group are damn good at what they do too. Grand Canyon felt like one of the most poignant performances of the night, Keenan’s surprisingly hypnotic voice seeming to echo into an abyss, reverberating around the room and filling the silence between drumbeats; surprisingly delicate harmonies were wistful, hauntingly human and yet decidedly otherworldly. As the track developed, it became quieter and more barren, rather than building towards the sort of crescendo you might expect. Somehow, that made it all the more affecting.
Contrasting it with Conditions of My Parole honestly just felt inspired. Beautiful and sparse to the darker, almost swampy and definitely quirky, it just drove home how different each album always feels. Throwing in another appearance by Dave Hill, cycling back on to knock out a few push-ups, only added to the absurdity. The resulting standing ovation — to the track and the set, not the push-ups — seemed to continue long enough to take even Puscifer by surprise.
Then, the time that Maynard always seems a little rueful about but always still offers. For those unaware, he’s strictly anti-filming/ anti-photography. Basically, no camera phones. But, at least for Puscifer, he always offers his crowds the chance to get those all important social media clips during the last song; though, he’s quick to plead his case beforehand. “Hearing and experiencing the song isn’t the same when you’re filming it,” he explained; “feel free to get your phones out and record this one, but notice the difference’.
And suddenly — the standing area especially — was alight with screens, although the lights shining forth from the little rectangles of death were the venomous green on stage.
The difference was palpable. Suddenly, the crowd are less present, more focussed on getting good pictures and views; on the other hand, it means you’ve got the clips to watch back after the gig and relive it. Grass is always greener, pros and cons, etc. It didn’t help that A Public Stoning was ridiculously good; both performance wise, seeming to jump between blisteringly loud and almost disturbingly quiet, and even just from a production standpoint, the lights going crazy. It would have felt rude not to record! A final appearance from Hill, too, tearing into his electric guitar as the evening drew to a close, felt fitting; you wouldn’t want such an ever-evolving, ever-advancing stage show to end in a semblance of normalcy after all!
There’s not really any sort of conclusion to be had — unless you count Puscifer as being both insanely good and just plain insane. Shame they get a third of Maynard’s creative energy, because most artists would kill for even a sprinkling of Puscifer magic to call their own. 10/10
Written By: James O’Sullivan










